top of page
Active Versus Passive Funds Which Fits Your Plan?

Active Versus Passive Funds Which Fits Your Plan?

Writer: Maria Temnyuk
Maria Temnyuk
2 days ago
6 min read

A fund choice can look minor on a statement, yet its effect compounds across decades. The active versus passive funds question is not about finding a universal winner. It is about deciding how each investment holding should serve your wider wealth plan, from KiwiSaver and retirement to property goals, lifestyle flexibility and future income.

For busy professionals and households, the real risk is making this decision by default. Choosing a fund because it performed well last year, because a colleague mentioned it, or because its label sounds reassuring is not a strategy. A clear decision starts with what you are trying to achieve, when you need the money, and how much volatility you can genuinely tolerate when markets fall.

Active versus passive funds: the decision behind the label

An actively managed fund has a professional investment team making deliberate decisions about what to buy, hold and sell. The manager may select individual companies, alter sector weightings, hold more cash, or move towards areas they believe are undervalued. The objective is usually to outperform a stated market benchmark after fees, or to deliver a specific outcome such as income, lower volatility or capital preservation.

A passive fund follows an index or defined market exposure. Rather than trying to identify the next winning company, it aims to hold the shares, bonds or other assets represented by that index. If the index rises or falls, the passive fund is designed to move broadly with it, less fees and trading costs.

Neither approach is automatically more sophisticated. Passive investing is a deliberate choice to accept market returns efficiently. Active investing is a deliberate choice to pay for judgement, research and portfolio decisions. The relevant question is whether that judgement has a credible role in your portfolio and whether the cost is justified.

Why fees deserve more attention than forecasts

Fees are one of the few investment variables you can identify before committing capital. They are not the only consideration, but they are certain. A higher-fee fund must deliver stronger returns before fees simply to keep pace with a lower-cost alternative tracking a similar market.

This gap can become meaningful over a long investment horizon. A difference that appears modest in a single year is applied repeatedly to an expanding balance. That is particularly relevant for KiwiSaver, where regular contributions and employer payments may remain invested for decades.

Low fees alone do not make a fund suitable. A low-cost global share fund could still be inappropriate if you need the money for a home deposit in two years. Equally, a more expensive active fund is not automatically poor value if it gives access to a specialist market, a carefully managed income mandate or a defensive approach that fits a defined purpose. The discipline is to ask what you are paying for, how success will be measured and how long you are prepared to assess it.

Passive funds offer broad exposure, not a free ride

Passive funds are often attractive because they are transparent, diversified and generally low cost. An investor can gain exposure to hundreds or thousands of businesses without relying on one manager’s conviction. For long-term growth capital, broad market exposure can be a powerful foundation.

But passive does not mean safe. A passive fund tracking global shares will still decline when global share markets decline. A fund following a concentrated local index may have substantial exposure to a small number of companies or sectors. Investors should understand the underlying index, the countries and currencies involved, and the level of share or bond market risk being accepted.

There is also no such thing as a neutral portfolio. An index is built using rules, often based on market size. That means the largest companies receive the greatest weighting, whether or not they are the best value at a given time. For many investors this is an acceptable and efficient trade-off. It should simply be understood rather than mistaken for complete diversification or guaranteed prudence.

Where active management can earn its place

Active management has a stronger case in some parts of a portfolio than others. Markets vary in how widely researched, liquid and efficiently priced they are. In highly followed developed share markets, consistently outperforming after fees is difficult. That does not make it impossible, but it sets a high bar for manager selection.

In specialist areas, less liquid markets, smaller companies, property securities, fixed interest or responsible-investment mandates, an experienced manager may have more scope to add value. In bond funds, for example, decisions on credit quality, duration and issuer selection can matter significantly, especially when interest rates and economic conditions are changing.

Active management can also be useful where the goal is more specific than simply matching an index. An investor drawing income in retirement may value a manager’s approach to preserving capital, managing distributions and reducing avoidable concentration. Someone with a strong preference around ethical exclusions may require a portfolio built with greater intention than a standard index provides.

The trade-off is that active outcomes differ widely. Some managers outperform, some underperform, and even skilled managers can have extended periods out of favour. Recent performance is evidence of what has happened, not a promise of what comes next. Manager process, team stability, mandate, fees and behaviour through difficult markets all deserve scrutiny.

Do not confuse activity with value

A manager making frequent trades is not necessarily adding value. Nor is a manager who holds a portfolio very similar to its benchmark while charging an active fee. This is often called closet indexing, and it should prompt a direct question: are you receiving genuine active judgement, or an expensive version of market exposure?

A sound review considers how different the portfolio is from its benchmark, the risks it takes to pursue returns, and whether its stated process is consistently applied. It also looks beyond a single quarter or calendar year. Good decisions can temporarily look uncomfortable when markets reward a narrow group of shares.

Build the portfolio around your objectives first

The most effective way to approach active and passive funds is to begin with the role of each pool of money. Capital needed in the near term should generally prioritise certainty and access. Capital intended for a retirement several decades away can usually accept more growth volatility, provided you can remain invested through market cycles.

Your wider balance sheet matters too. A household with significant residential property exposure already has meaningful concentration in New Zealand property and the local economy. That may strengthen the case for diversified investments across regions, industries and asset types. It may also affect how much additional risk you should take elsewhere.

For many investors, the answer is not exclusively active or exclusively passive. A core-and-satellite structure can combine low-cost passive funds for broad market exposure with carefully selected active funds where there is a defined reason to use them. The allocation should be intentional, not an accumulation of products acquired at different stages of life.

This approach can also make reviews clearer. You can assess the passive core against its index and costs, while assessing each active allocation against the specific job it was given to do. If an active manager no longer meets that standard, you have a framework for change rather than reacting to headlines.

Questions to ask before committing

Before selecting a fund, establish the purpose of the investment, your time horizon and the maximum loss you could withstand without abandoning the plan. Then examine the fund’s asset allocation, fees, diversification, tax structure and liquidity. New Zealand investors should also consider whether the fund is a PIE fund and how its tax treatment works alongside their wider position.

For active funds, ask what the manager does differently, why that advantage may persist, and what would make you reconsider the holding. For passive funds, ask which index is being tracked, how concentrated it is, and whether the exposure duplicates other investments you already own.

A good fund can still be the wrong fund if it conflicts with your cash-flow needs, debt reduction priorities or property plans. Investment selection is an implementation decision. It should follow the strategy, not replace it.

Markets will continue to produce confident predictions and short-term winners. Your advantage is not predicting the next one. It is holding a portfolio you understand, can afford to maintain and have deliberately positioned for the life you want to build.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page